The first meeting of the congregation occurred in 1801, the first organized church in the town of Vernon, New York. They organized formally in 1802.

A List of all Pastors since 1802

From 200 Years of Vernon Center’s Presbyterian Church, by Dr. H. Eugene Butler.

1802 – Rev. John Spencer

1803 – Rev. Publius Bogue (sometimes spelled Booge)

1803 – Rev. Palmer

1805 – Rev. James Eells

1805 – Rev. Kirby

1807 – Rev. A. S. Norton

1810 – Rev. John Smith

1811 – Rev. Calvin Bushnell

1817 Rev. Orange Lyman

1824 Rev. John Barton

1827 Rev. B. J. Lane

1828 – Rev. James Boyle

1828 – Rev. Horatio Foot

1828 – Rev. Lucious Foot

1829 – Rev. E. M. Spencer

1830 – Rev. Calvin Bushnell

1831 – Rev. E. N. Nicholas

1833 – Rev. John Waters

1834 – Rev. Dunham

1835 – Rev. Clark

1835 – Rev. Alfred Hough

1840 – Rev. S.P.M. Hastings

1842 – Rev. John Dodd (church divided over slavery/abolition)

1842 – Rev. s. Strong

1843 – Rev. George Gridley

1843 – Rev. Samuel Whaley

1847 – Rev~ R. A. Avery

1855 – Rev. Elijah Bonney

1873 – Rev. E. C. Ray

1876 – Rev. E. C. Smith

1878 – Rev. M. F. Tripp

1879 – Rev. J. F. Nason

1882 – Rev. Stanley-Roberts

1888 – Rev. C. H. Van Wie

1890 – Rev. C. M. Dodge

1890 – Rev. David Biggar

1900 – Rev. C.H. Dudley

1902 – Rev. H. H. Kellogg

1908 – Rev. John Williams

1910 – Rev. Frank West

1918 – Rev. J.B. Grant

1923 – Rev. Frank West

1927 – Rev. L. D. Jarrard

1937 – Rev. John MacQuarrie

1945 – Rev. Walter Brock

1950 – Rev. John Craig, Jr.

1953 – Mr. Myron Bellinger

1954 – Rev. John Morris

1958 – Rev. Ernest Smyth

1965 – Rev. Richard Stitt

1970 – Rev. Ernest Bittner

1975 – Rev. William Patterson

1983 – Rev. James Bender

1983 – Rev. R. Kraus-Neale

1984 – Mr. Elden T. Shaut

1992 – 2002 – Rev. P. Arthur Brindisi

2003-2005 – Jay G. Williams III

<